
What if the purpose of something being difficult was to intentionally lead to development? What if the point of struggling was to spur growth? What would things be like if the reason something led to a struggle was so that someone could learn?
In some cases, erasing barriers can generate ease and make things more accessible. But what if the friction is the point?
Those are the sorts of conversations that leaders from LeTourneau University, the Christian Polytechnic University, are having right now. Those discussions happen to coincide with and overlap the conversations surrounding artificial intelligence’s place in our world, humanity, vocation, purpose, belonging, and education.
As LETU President Dr. Steven D. Mason puts it plainly, “One of our strategic goals over the next decade is to be a nationally trusted voice in faith, science, and technology.” And as he further explained, every discipline at LeTourneau has a stake in the questions AI raises.
“Just because you can do something, should you? And not just, what is this? What can I do with this technology? But also, what is it doing to me?”
The impacts of AI are far-reaching across our society.
Dr. Kelly Liebengood, Dean of the School of Theology and Vocation, looked back on when AI first arrived on the scene and the sort of impact that was immediately felt. The debates were fierce. Some bought in and believed that AI would immediately change everything. Others were quick to be dismissive, stating that everything about AI was all flash and lacked substance.
While Liebengood was talking about the original AI, Allen Iverson, the comparisons carry over.
Liebengood’s joke landed well with the crowd, and it was the perfect opportunity to deliver a serious point. Within society, artificial intelligence has been both warmly embraced and also strongly resisted.
And with this joke as the vehicle, Liebengood noted that this all raises a collection of deeper questions.
“Whatever you feel about AI and this rapid emergence, one thing is clear,” Liebengood said. “It presents us with an amazing opportunity, an opportunity to think more deeply about what makes for a good life, about what power and technology are for, about what we’re becoming in this technological age that we live in, about what aspects of our humanity we’re in danger of losing. And at the root of all of this is an assumption, a vision, about what it means to be human.”
That group of questions is what laid the foundation for Forever His Image: Faith, AI & Human Flourishing, an evening panel that LeTourneau University hosted Nov. 12 at Coram Deo Academy in Richardson. At the Christian Polytechnic University, LETU’s leaders help to make up the right group to explore these questions.
Liebengood was joined on stage by five leaders from LeTourneau: Dr. Michael McGinnis, Dean of the School of Engineering and Engineering Technology; Dr. Matthew Eppinette, executive director of The Center for Bioethics & Human Dignity; Dr. Jonathan Lett, director of the Faith,
Science, and Technology Initiative; Dr. Jeffrey Quiett, professor of psychology and counseling; and Dr. Kimberly Quiett, Dean of the School of Nursing.
What we must protect in the age of AI
To kick the panel off, Liebengood posed a question for LeTourneau’s leaders.
As AI is woven into our lives, what essential part of being human must we protect? What needs to be cultivated?
As the engineer on the panel, McGinnis started by unpacking how AI operates. To make it straightforward, he compared the process to a family working on a jigsaw puzzle with the spilling of pieces and assembling and arranging that takes place. As McGinnis noted, people supply the knowledge, design the algorithms, and judge the answers.
“What are humans? Humans are beautiful,” he said. “They’re made in the image of God. And what else are we? We’re fallen too.”
Eppinette pointed to the body.
“We could have been created as free-floating spirits, but we weren’t,” he said, crediting author Nancy Pearcey. "The Incarnation," he added, "underscores that God values face-to-face, embodied presence."
Those notions were further emphasized by Jeffrey Quiett, who noted that our problems and issues are part of what makes us human.
Kimberly Quiett said LeTourneau’s nursing students learn to care for the
fullness of a person’s humanity all while using every tool available. That said, technology can’t “take the place of seeing the person as a whole person.”
And Lett noted that humans grow through a slow process, which is something that can contrast with why many find AI an attractive option.
The trap of chasing efficiency
“AI didn’t just drop out of the sky,” Lett said. “It emerged out of a current that’s already been moving our culture.”
“Culture is simply what human beings make and what human beings make reflects our values. It reflects the things we care about, the things we love, the things we want to see in life,” Lett continued.
For decades, technology has been built to expedite processes, expand choice, and offer new levels of control. As Lett notes, that has led to efficiency and productivity being among the chief values of modern life. And while that works well in some settings, like a microwave, that doesn’t mean it’ll work in all aspects of life.
“What if I were to tell you that I have a wonderful marriage? It’s the most efficient marriage,” he said. “I spend as little time as possible with my wife and we get the most out of it.”
“Efficiency and productivity are not values you should reach for when trying to think about a marriage or raising children,” Lett said.
Growing and learning take time, Lett argues, whether that’s in business, education, or our prayer lives.
“It takes struggle. It takes failure. It’s very slow,” Lett said. “And by the way, that’s part of the gift of being human.”
Image bearers instead of machines
Eppinette leads The Center for Bioethics & Human Dignity, which has studied emerging technology and ethics for more than 30 years. As he
notes, flourishing is not the same as being efficient or productive. That’s more closely centered around when people are rightly related to God, to one another, and to their tools.
“They’re not animals, they’re not gadgets, they’re not objects,” Eppinette said. “[They’re] image bearers.”
Jeffrey Quiett, who directs LETU’s Counseling Center, has seen what happens when people forget that.
“We get people in the counseling center who see themselves as machines and therefore want a counselor to fix the machine,” he said.
As he further explained, despite the rise in technology and its capabilities, that doesn’t mean a drop in requests for counseling has taken place. He’s training future counselors accordingly as AI can simulate empathy but that therapeutic relationships are a key to healing.
“Empathy, understanding, connection is the treatment,” Jeffrey Quiett said
“The treatment is the relationship.”
A balance of technology and humanity
While there are words of warning and considerations to take place when using AI, the panel isn’t anti-technology.
There’s a balance that needs to be present.
“I am pro-technology,” Kimberly Quiett said, noting that the tools nurses use save lives. She described a recent conversation with a radiologist touring LETU’s nursing program with his daughter. At his practice, AI gives incoming ER CT scans a quick first read and moves any possible brain bleed to the top of the list, where minutes matter.
Nursing students at LeTourneau learn to use that kind of technology well, she said, but also to use “our eyes, our ears, our nose, our hands to understand that person.”
And it’s not just LETU’s nursing students who are growing in their care for others.
McGinnis and the School of Engineering and Engineering Technology emphasize a model of a “lowercase t-shaped engineer.”
Engineering has long described a “capital T” engineer, with deep technical skills along with broad relational skills. The lowercase t adds a point at the top, aimed at Christ. When a LETU theologian told him God can’t be treated as one piece of a model, McGinnis agreed, but argued that the shape of the lowercase t already makes that point, and the theologian liked it.
“The shape itself is essentially a theological claim,” McGinnis said.
As a result, McGinnis has a different definition of engineering that flows from this.
“The working out of the great commandment to love God and love people through the use of math and science to solve problems that help build the kingdom,” McGinnis explained.
Of course, he checked that answer with an AI. It told him the answer was too long.
What does a healthy use of AI look like?
When given the chance to field questions from the audience, LeTourneau’s leaders were able to discuss some practical elements about AI in life today.
How do faculty persuade students to do their own work when there are AI chatbots that could field it for them?
McGinnis said it comes down to the difference between “I have to do my homework” and “I get to do my homework.” He sends faculty a monthly reminder to tell students that “the friction is the point.”
Lett approaches things similarly with a gym analogy. Actually engaging in reading through a text and wrestling with an idea provides students with the opportunity to learn. Students can build what he calls “intellectual muscle.
“If you’re struggling and failing, that makes me really happy,” he said. “I’m not evil. I’m just a good coach.”
He has also told students that since AI went mainstream, his class has posted its lowest exam and final-paper scores in more than 20 times teaching it.
And when someone should decide when to use AI?
There are tests for that.
Jeffrey Quiett said that using it to avoid something, such as pain, a hard relationship, or difficult emotions, is a warning sign. McGinnis suggested asking whether you would be proud to explain your use of AI to a mentor. Lett warned that every shortcut shapes character: “The more times you hit the easy button, the more you become a kind of person who needs the easy button.”
As for the use of AI in the workforce? There’s a balance to strike.
“In our work as nurses, I would not want a robot coming to my bedside if my heart rate was dropping and my respirations were going low, and I was about to die,” Kimberly Quiett said. “I want a human there to hold my hand.”